Skip to content

How Accessibility Exceptions and Exclusions Came to Be

Most accessibility laws, like the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Section 508, are shaped by a mix of historical legal precedent, lobbying, and political compromises. When these laws were created, lawmakers had to determine who should be required to comply and what the limits of enforcement should be.

Some key reasons why exceptions exist:

  1. Constitutional Protections - The First Amendment protects religious organizations from certain types of government regulation, including employment and, in some cases, accessibility requirements.
  2. Legislative Compromise - Many laws were shaped through negotiations where businesses and advocacy groups fought for different levels of regulation. Some industries successfully lobbied to reduce their obligations.
  3. Scope of the Law - Some laws were designed for specific sectors (e.g., public accommodations vs. private employers), which created gaps where certain organizations were left out.

Who Gets Excluded and Why?

  1. Religious Organizations - Generally exempt from ADA Title I (employment) and Title III (public accommodations). They don't have to make places of worship accessible, even if open to the public.
  2. Private Clubs - If an organization is truly private (not open to the public), it might be exempt under Title III.
  3. Small Businesses - The ADA doesn't require compliance for companies with fewer than 15 employees under Title I.
  4. Certain Digital Spaces - U.S. law has been slow to explicitly regulate web accessibility, leaving room for legal loopholes.

How These Decisions Were Made

  1. ADA (1990) - Religious exemptions were included largely due to pressure from religious institutions, arguing they should not be forced to modify doctrine or structures.
  2. Section 508 (1998 & Refresh 2017) - Government-related, so it doesn't apply to private businesses or nonprofits, limiting its reach.
  3. State-Level Laws - Some states go beyond the ADA and require compliance from organizations that would otherwise be exempt.

Where is this going?

There's growing pressure to close some of these gaps. Lawsuits and policy changes (like the DOJ's web accessibility proposal in 2023) suggest that digital spaces and small businesses may face stricter requirements soon.

Recent Legal Updates

  • Ride-Sharing Services and Accessibility: Despite technological advancements, ride-sharing platforms like Uber and Lyft have faced criticism for inadequate accessibility measures. In October 2024, protests highlighted ongoing discrimination against visually impaired passengers, particularly those with guide dogs. Advocates are urging these companies to implement stricter anti-discrimination policies and better driver education to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Wired.
  • International Perspectives: The European Court of Human Rights addressed accessibility in the case of Toplak and Mrak v. Slovenia (2021). The court ruled that Slovenia violated the rights of disabled voters by not providing adequate access to polling stations, emphasizing the necessity for proactive measures to ensure accessibility in electoral processes. Wikipedia.

Impactful Case Studies

  • Web Accessibility Litigation: The 2006 case National Federation of the Blind v. Target Corp. set a precedent for web accessibility. The lawsuit alleged that Target's website was not accessible to blind users, leading to a settlement where Target agreed to improve its website's accessibility and paid $6 million in damages. This case underscored the importance of digital accessibility and motivated other companies to evaluate their online platforms for ADA compliance. Wikipedia.
  • Urban Infrastructure and Major Events: In preparation for the 2024 Paralympics, Paris undertook significant efforts to enhance city-wide accessibility. Improvements included upgrading public transportation and public spaces to accommodate individuals with disabilities. However, challenges persisted, particularly with the historic metro system, highlighting the complexities cities face in balancing heritage preservation with modern accessibility needs. Cntraveler.
Back to top